After a lifetime in law, John Minton feels ‘unfinished’
BOWLING GREEN, Ky. (WNKY) – When the Supreme Court of Kentucky unveiled a portrait of John D. Minton Jr. on Nov. 6 in Frankfort, the Bowling Green native saw what he called “a mark of finality.” The ceremony honored his 17 years on the state’s highest court, including 14 as chief justice of Kentucky.
The books that drew him to law
Minton’s father taught history at Western Kentucky University, and Minton grew up hearing conversations about history and government at home. In his elementary school library, he found a row of biographies and started reading.
“I noticed a pattern that a lot of those folks, many of them, had training in the law, so I thought, well, that’s what I want to do,” Minton recalled. “I want to make a difference.”
When Minton came home to practice law, he sat across a desk from attorney Norman Harned, who reviewed the young lawyer’s work with him. Minton called the time Harned and fellow attorney John David Cole spent teaching him “a great, great gift.”
The kind of judge he wanted to be
Minton’s cases took him into courtrooms across Kentucky, where he watched other judges work. “And when I saw judges who treated jurors and witnesses and parties and lawyers with courtesy and respect, I admired that, and I wanted it to be like that,” he said.
As a circuit judge in Bowling Green, Minton wanted jurors to leave knowing their time mattered. He went on to serve on the Kentucky Court of Appeals and the state Supreme Court before retiring in January 2023.
Life after the bench
“I still feel sort of pretty much unfinished,” Minton shared. A Bowling Green law firm gives him a place to “fix a cup of coffee, and sit down, and tell war stories.” He also tends a garden and beehives and spends time with his 5-year-old grandson.
Once renovations are complete, his portrait will join those of former justices on the second floor of the Kentucky State Capitol. Minton hopes future generations will see “good ancestors” in those faces. “So they’ll fix our mistakes, and maybe benefit from some of the good things we did as well,” he said.